Splicetoday

Politics & Media
Nov 17, 2026, 06:26AM

The Democrats’ Politics of Trauma

Whether the Party’s leadership will embrace rationality is an open question.

Dems jeffries ap 2026 11 03 768x512.jpg?ixlib=rails 2.1

Non-Hispanic white people represent 60 percent of the U.S. population, by far the largest racial demographic in the nation. Normally this would mean that both major political parties would place a high priority on appealing to as many white men as possible, but the Democrats are exclusive, like a posh country club. To get in, a white male must have a degree, even though 65 percent of them don't. No political science degree is needed to see the problem with these numbers, but the Dems don't stop at ignoring the “uneducated”—approximately 20 percent of all eligible voters. They denigrate them. No party placing the highest priority on winning intentionally alienates potential voters with personal attacks, which is a big reason why there've been two Trump presidencies.

Why a party with such power would choose to hamstring itself is beyond reason. Abandoning basic electoral realities to run with the social experiment known as “identity politics” can’t be explained with logic, as it's faith-based. It's ironic that the same progressives who've abandoned religious faith have now turned to a different faith, making them reliant on the iffy proposition of pulling together a coalition of minorities that have little or nothing in common. Obama pulled it off, but that was an anomaly. Where, for example, would a political discussion between the “trans community” and Muslim-Americans even begin?

The Democrats, with their new power, have an opportunity to embrace more rational politics by emphasizing issues that voters care about, but will they? The hopeful underestimate the massive entrenched power standing in the way of such obvious progress. They're unaware that there’s a “deep state” consisting of an interlocking network of NGOs, government agencies, private foundations, and corporate donors that has too much too lose if their party turns away from what's come to be called “trauma politics”—the politics of individual suffering revolving around the question, “What's been done to us, and how can we redress all the wrongs?”

The trauma politics deep state—let’s call it TPDS—is made up of shape-shifters. In public, they exude empathy with carefully scripted words. But in their boardrooms the tone shifts to a more self-serving agenda. For example, after over $90 million flowed into the organization’s coffers in 2020, BLM co-founder Patrisse Cullors paid out $840,000 to her brother for his “security” work. New York magazine reported that the brother supervised security at Cullors’ four residences. That's what's called, in legal terms, “self-dealing.” Also, that's a lot of homes for a civil rights crusader.

If an organization depends on the existence of a particular cause of trauma, fixing that problem threatens it. This is called the "cobra effect,” a situation in which there's a perverse incentive to manage or prolong a crisis rather than eliminate it. Self-centered organizations may downplay crafting long-term solutions in favor of high-profile campaigns, outrage churning, or symbolic gestures that generate donations and media attention.

Paying a brother big bucks to guard your real estate portfolio is a spectacular example, but the real danger of the TPDS is how far downstream it flows into American life—all the way to the nation's top orchestras. On February 2 of this year, the board of the Boston Symphony Orchestra voted to terminate its contract with conductor Andris Nelsons, who'd served as the BSO’s music director since 2014. Under Nelsons, ticket sales had risen steadily, but the board concluded: “Andris was not the right leader for the entirety of our institution and our community.” In January, 2024, the board rewrote his contract to renew automatically, citing its “deep confidence” in his “artistic leadership.” But a March 6 press release stated that the beloved maestro was “not aligned on future vision” of the BSO.

Future vision of music fans and the orchestra’s patrons? The orchestra’s president and CEO, Chad Smith, is the quintessence of the modern arts administrator—fluent in both DEI-speak and corporate woke-speak. After a prolonged silence, on June 30 Smith told a Boston radio host that the new leadership of the BSO board had “landed at a place where we felt that the organization, that the orchestra, must serve Boston, must serve our communities more expansively and inclusively.”

The orchestra is furious about their maestro getting fired. According to Smith, Nelsons wasn’t supportive of this new direction, “particularly as it related to how we think about expansively serving our communities.” Smith continued, speaking about putting new voices on BSO stages who need to be heard—”whose stories get to be told.” He added the need to address “systemic” issues. The woke-speak code words—”stories,” “communities,” “systemic”—aren't hard to decipher.

So classical music’s now about telling stories from the various communities it serves? And who gets to tell those stories isn't connected to their musical ability? That sounds like the artistic message behind the dull, cookie-cutter Communist art of the government-controlled "Socialist Realism" movement in the 1950s.

Substitute agenda-driven administrators for apparatchiks and you have the bloated power structure of the BSO, which once had six administrators but now has 200—one for each orchestra member. From the top down, the leadership structure of that orchestra sees its mission as addressing the trauma caused by the racist policies of the past. And there are also 200 salaries at stake.

Nelsons’ sin was requesting the restoration of a key phrase—”Make artistic excellence the core mission of the BSO”—that had been deleted from the organization’s strategic plan. That's all it took to send him packing—when his contract expires—to Europe, where he’s music director of Germany's Leipzig Gewandhaus Orchestra.

In the Texas midterms, James Talarico winning a U.S. Senate seat and Gina Hinojosa taking the governorship was astounding in that it ended a three-decade statewide Democratic victory drought in Texas. Those two won not by lecturing Texans from their perch of moral superiority and as the Democrats did in 2024, but by speaking plainly and with empathy about the economic struggles shared by all the state's residents. This is a positive sign, but there's a huge iceberg hidden underneath the water impeding future progress. The Trauma Politics Deep State is embedded within universities (the University of Michigan has 220 DEI advisors) and important cultural institutions like the BSO all across the nation.

Discussion

Register or Login to leave a comment