The essay film has never taken off in America—well, I’m not sure it’s “taken off” anywhere in the world, but there are always more of them in any country with government subsidies for the arts. Commercial cinema remains conservative for obvious reasons, and even a “genre-bending” hit like You Can See Everything can only go so deep. Anyone familiar with Nathan Fielder’s work up to this point must admit that, regardless of their opinion on his latest, The Curse and both seasons of The Rehearsal went places that few movies do, all while expanding the limits of television without ever becoming predictable, ponderous, or pretentious. A crucial difference between Fielder’s previous work and You Can See Everything is the latter’s co-director, Lance Oppenheim, a prolific documentarian who never uses voice over narration, unlike Fielder. Without his commentary, the movie feels baggier and more bloated than it should; it’s also an easy way out, a way to make a movie for all seasons. Mission accomplished: Amanda Seyfried might get an Oscar nomination for reprising her role as Elizabeth Holmes in a series of dramatic recreations—but that’s not what the buzz is all about. Seyfried might get nominated for an Oscar for arguing with Billy Evans, Holmes’ right-wing husband. Never mind that she comes off as a fairly stupid and callous actor at the end, stumped and frustrated by Fielder remarkably quickly; that nomination, if it should come, will be for Seyfried’s criticism of Evans and Charlie Kirk (Evans was “a fan of his,” which tells the audience that he’s a villain beyond redemption).
Nevertheless, the success of You Can See Everything has paved the way for more formally experimental films in the American commercial cinema. Would audiences in 2026 go for something like Henry Fonda for President? Maybe not, but I bet they’d turn Tom Cruise for President into a hit. Alexander Horwath’s 2024 essay film premiered at the Berlinale nearly three years ago and topped year-end lists around the world; the few Americans who saw it at the time raved, even Armond White, who didn’t fail to criticize Horwath’s naif political commentary, called it “monumental” and “both fascinating and “infuriating.” Because there are only four movie theaters in Baltimore City—FOUR!—there was no way Henry Fonda for President was ever going to make it here. Maybe at the pre-pandemic Parkway, but now? No. I’m just glad I got see Jean-Luc Godard’s The Image Book, his final film and his best, three times at the Parkway in early-February 2019. That was an essay film by a master, and besides their liberal use of John Ford’s Young Mr. Lincoln, there are more similarities between Horwath and Godard’s films.
Like Godard, Horwath constructs a scaffolding of meaning and resonance across American history and Hollywood history, collaging clips from dozens and dozens of Fonda films like You Only Live Once, The Wrong Man, The Best Man, Fail-Safe, Mister Roberts, and Once Upon a Time in the West, along with his numerous collaborations with Ford; additional material like audio interviews, television appearances, cameos, and contemporary footage of the United States is used to weave together a grand portrait of at least three histories: America, Hollywood, and the Fondas, from Dutch settlers to Jane and Peter. There are revelations among the film’s three hours: I knew that Fonda’s wife Frances committed suicide while institutionalized, but I had no idea that that was the reason Alfred Hitchcock cast him in The Wrong Man. Made just five years after Frances’ death, The Wrong Man tells the true story of Manny Balestrero, accused of a crime he didn’t commit and sent through the bowels of the American criminal justice system. He’s cleared by the end of the movie, but it’s just about destroyed his wife Vera Miles, on the verge of a nervous breakdown and close to institutionalization herself by the movie’s remarkably unresolved and downbeat ending. It’s impossible not to notice the resemblance between Miles and Frances Fonda here.
What emerges is a thorough examination of one of Classic Hollywood’s greatest “auteur actors”: people like Cary Grant, James Stewart, Humphrey Bogart, and Clark Gable, men who made “personal films” simply by picking the material they thought suited them. Fonda modestly tells Dick Cavett in the early-1970s that, “people think I have a point of view, but I just pick the best script, the best story, and I go with that.” Another guest chimes in: “But it’s the way you tell it, no? That has an enormous effect.” Fonda looks up, stumped. It wasn’t an entirely conscious process, but one that’s almost impossible to practice now because of the relative dearth of material in Hollywood and the stifling self-consciousness that pervades our century. Again, Tom Cruise may be the only analogue here: an actor who’s never written or directed a film but whose body of work nonetheless coheres and forms as clear a vision as any of the directors in Andrew Sarris’ American Cinema.
Horwath gets off track occasionally with some exceptionally stupid and already painfully dated bits of sermonizing, lamenting “the sacred Lakota mountain” that was blown up to make way for Mount Rushmore, a monument featuring four presidents “who no women voted for.” Christ, here we go… later, we learn that Tuckahoe, hometown of Maude from Maude, has recently elected its first mayor who is a “female person of color.” You can just hear Fonda in that final 1980 interview rasping, “What is this shit?” You can tell from the footage shot in Times Square that this film was made in the early pandemic years: when people leave a performance of Hamilton, most people have their masks on, but several don’t—late-2022? Early-2023? Earlier, maybe? Footage of a nearby Trump impersonator is unintentionally amusing, never foreboding or ominous, just another presidential caricature, one far less threatening than the JFK analogue Fonda played in Fail-Safe.
Horwath tries to make connections between the “Okies” of The Grapes of Wrath and the Latin and Mexican workers of today; at one point he flaccidly notes that “there’s private and public housing for the migrant workers. The public housing is in better shape.” Okay. The fuck does this have to do with the Dust Bowl or Henry Fonda? The last hour of Henry Fonda for President falls into the childish parlor game of assigning contemporary politics to long-dead 20th-century filmmakers who can’t defend themselves or refute anyone. Horwath positions Fonda as a “leftwing radical,” despite Fonda’s protests against such a label; he admits that Nixon was “a real creep” and that Ronald Reagan’s election is “a disaster… he’s putting us on a course that we’ll be on for a long time.” Well, he got that right. Still doesn’t make him a dialectical Marxist or a revolutionary in waiting. Fonda was a rich movie star who could afford to grow his own food, not someone who watched Salt of the Earth religiously.
I was surprised that Fonda’s mangier 1970s movies—Ash Wednesday, Fedora, Rollercoaster—didn’t even rate a mention. But Horwath begins and ends with the obvious choice: On Golden Pond, Fonda’s last film and one of Hollywood’s greatest meta-triumphs, a movie that surely works on a blind viewing but is immeasurably enhanced by a lifetime’s knowledge and media familiarity with the Fondas, just as the opening scene of Once Upon a Time in the West will never be as powerful as it was to audiences in 1968. Henry Fonda for President is a masterful work of collage, and although hampered slightly by its already dated and mostly clueless view of America through a European lens, it’s an essential examination of one of our country’s greatest film actors, a man who was regarded as a hero long before his death at the age of 77 in 1982.
—Follow Nicky Otis Smith on Twitter: @NARCFILM
