The following phone message was left by a female person claiming to be a student at the University of Mississippi to the father of another Ole Miss student: “Scott, I'm going to hang your daughter. I'm going to hang the bitch. I live in Mississippi and I go to that school. You'd best not send your daughter back to that school. Alaina will be hung Monday morning from the nearest tree if you send her to school.”
Alaina Kunes is one of the two Ole Miss female students—another one was with them but she didn't participate—who've been identified as having made monkey noises and gestures on the evening of November 6th outside the door of an apartment occupied by several of their black female classmates—all caught on a Ring camera. No information has yet emerged indicating that the girls had been drinking. The video went viral, quickly attracting 12 million views. Kunes, 18, received threats and has since withdrawn from the University. The second student, yet to be reliably identified, purportedly continued her performance even after the residents of the apartment came out into the hallway, but her side of the story hasn’t been heard yet.
Shortly after the incident, Kunes issued a public apology through a law firm: “Before the incident on Nov. 6, I never met the women involved and was unaware of their race, however I recognize my actions were insensitive, inappropriate and deeply harmful. I would have never intentionally made those noises or gestures toward a person of color. I have apologized to the women and I pray they will forgive me.”
According to one of those women, Kunes told her that her group had been behaving similarly outside of four other apartments that night. The media has reported that the black students have “disputed” that explanation, saying they hadn’t seen evidence of the other doors being targeted. They can dispute it, but that doesn't mean they know whether or not it happened. Perhaps they never will, unless one of those four apartments in question also had a Ring camera. The university is investigating the incident. A proper investigation must involve identifying those four apartments and speaking to all of their residents.
My instant reaction was disgust. The Mississippi location reinforced this feeling—and a feeling is all it was. Nobody could draw a factual conclusion from the short clip. Daniel Kahneman, a psychologist and Nobel prize-winning economist, described the trap so many have fallen into with this case (and many similar ones) with his WYSIATI (What You See Is All There Is) concept. According to Kahneman, the human mind has a tendency to construct the most coherent theory possible from the information immediately available, without adequately considering what is missing.
People rarely stop to consider that there's evidence they haven't seen, exaggerated when race is involved. Who can forget the Jussie Smollett and his fake Chicago hate crime, the Duke University Lacrosse manufactured rape case, and black NASCAR racer Bubba Wallace’s faux “noose” that turned out to be a garage door pull rope that had been there for months before the driver was assigned sign that garage? The media behaved recklessly in all three of these cases and similar ones that've occurred.
The reason the nation doesn't ever learn from these fake hate crimes is that the Left, with its trauma politics, has created a demand for them that exceeds the supply. They need more real victims than they can find. Therefore, they must be manufactured. Incidents that’re initially interpreted as evidence of racism will always generate enormous public attention, so there's a built-in tendency to hype them before the facts are in. If they turn out to be fake, the public still clings to the initial reporting, which is unfortunate for the falsely accused. They're just collateral damage in the war on racism. It's similar to what's happening to the “Cornell 7.” Some on the Left promote the idea that there's a “rape culture” in the nation. While there's plenty of evidence indicating that the Cornell frat bros are guilty of nothing other than loutishness, those claiming “rape” ignore it in favor of the presumption of guilt.
The demand for victims and the reach of social media means that incidents that once were local stories now become national. With this Mississippi incident, just like similar ones in the past, the media’s made little effort to explain why the accused may be innocent. While the presumption of innocence is a cornerstone of American jurisprudence, the media doesn't operate that way.
Although I haven’t seen any media reports of this, it’s obvious the two white women were performing for the camera. Why else would they make simian-like gestures in addition to the noises when there's nobody there to see them? Why did one of them put her face inches from the camera? And what student would go on record like that if the intent was racial taunting? It's guaranteed that such a video will go viral and wreck the lives of the perpetrators, regardless of their culpability. Every 18-year-old in the country knows this. Kunes apologized to the black students for upsetting them, not because she was acting like a racist.
CBS News, without waiting for the results of the Ole Miss investigation, had Jericka Duncan interview the black students as if their victimhood were already a given. She asked them how they “felt” after seeing the Ring video, which is irrelevant because they lacked the context to understand what they were seeing. When one claimed that only their door was targeted, Duncan failed to do her job by asking her how she knew that. Another student said that even if the white girls had done the same thing outside four other apartments, they shouldn't have done that because it's “disrespectful.” It may be disrespectful, but in that case it would not have been not racially motivated.
Being young, dumb and acting like a goofball, which is what probably happened, can come with a high price today. And the media won't lift a finger to do anything about it.
