Mind games and murder isn’t what Norah Larkin bargained for. She didn’t bargain for being so unceremoniously and cowardly dumped either. She loved her sweetheart, yet he decided that a nurse in Korea was a better bet than a girl in Los Angeles who’s patiently (and it turns out foolishly) waiting for his return from the war.
By chance, and in the moment of pure rage and desperation, Norah goes to dinner with Harry Prebble, a sketch artist and a self-professed womanizer. She meets Harry at The Blue Gardenia, a hip Chinese restaurant in LA, gets drunk on Polynesian Pearl Divers, while Nat King Cole plays and sings. She accepts going to Harry’s apartment.
It was all meant to be just a good time—something to do to forget about the scoundrel that tossed her aside. But waking up in her own apartment, hearing that Harry Prebble has been murdered, and convincing herself that she did it isn’t the life Norah imagined or wanted. She’s entered a nightmare of drunken amnesia.
Darkness looms in Fritz Lang’s noir The Blue Gardenia (1953), tinged with humor and battle of the sexes. Anne Baxter plays Norah Larkin, and her path doesn’t just cross with Harry Prebble (Raymond Burr) but with Casey Mayo (Richard Conte), a journalist who’s trying to out “the blue gardenia” murderess. Casey’s only interested in a good and breaking story—do whatever you have to do to sell it to the readers. He appears to have no scruples, and is no different than any other liar on the street.
But when Norah contacts him with a desire to tell the truth—which is that she believes she murdered Prebble but can’t remember anything—Casey changes his tune. He begins to fall in love with her, despite the possibility that this woman may be a manipulative liar who murdered a man in cold blood.
Not that anyone is missing Harry Prebble. His employer doesn’t think that highly of him and the only thing he’s bringing to the womenfolk is more pain and frustration. But he couldn’t care less. When another woman—Rose Miller—calls him, insisting that he marries her, Prebble callously dismisses her.
Things do resolve on a slightly happier note but like most noir films, and especially in the case of Fritz Lang, there’s an alienation in America. Post-war consciousness is in full swing only to be thrown into another war—this time in Korea. War may appear as a silly subtext in the film and something that provides initial tension and conflict, but it’s the catalyst for Norah’s later misfortune.
At the same time, she’s naive, and that has nothing to do with one war or the other. Her one roommate is even more psychologically removed from the erotic games men and women play. She’s satisfied with an endless stream of dime-store mysteries. By contrast, Norah’s second roommate, Crystal (Ann Sothern), is a mature woman, already divorced, yet in an allegedly better relationship with her ex-husband. She instructs Norah that it’s better to play hard to get, but what happens when it’s too late?
Most of the characters are aimlessly floating in life, dedicated to their individuality, independence, and are unable to settle down. Casey only has flings (phone numbers of women he keeps in a little black book) but something changes when he meets Norah. Is it pity? Is it the fact that her situation doesn’t make her a dull woman? Casey’s a man who wants excitement because his job demands it, and he’s not averse to some “hard to get” play that comes at the end. He loves a challenge but one wonders whether that’ll be enough to sustain the relationship with Norah.
The Blue Gardenia offers a picture of American life that revels in its emptiness and alienation while at the same time searches for more. This may be the post-war consciousness at play but it’s also hauntingly geographic. Los Angeles: a place of misfits who are willing to live alienated lives while unable to extract themselves from cowardice. They lack the courage to give themselves to another. Norah has this courage at the beginning, even if it’s grounded in naivete. But as time passes, this wide-eyed lightness turns into indifference. She lacks the strength to think on her own, clear at the end of the film. Will she continue to be under the spell of Crystal’s pseudo-wisdom of female power or Casey’s charm? She’s too sincere, and sincerity has no place in L.A.
