Splicetoday

Music
May 16, 2008, 07:07AM

The New Guitar Solo Canon

Which bands are overlooked when discussing the most recognizable guitar sounds in the biz? And can we please get over Slash?

Feelies.jpg?ixlib=rails 2.1

Photo of a ticket from the Feelies' "last show" in 1991 by 536

Lately, I've submerged myself in fuzzed out, psychedelic guitar sounds from around the world. I have one record from an old Nigerian group that sounds like a spaced out version of the Allman Brothers. Another album comes from a band called Group Doueh out of Western Sahara. Their self-produced record, released by Sublime Frequencies, is only available on vinyl (which makes sense considering that the recording is so lo-fi it makes Times New Viking sound polished) and it shakes and wobbles with Hendrix-esque guitar licks. For a band isolated in this unpopulated North African region, they have no business sounding this Western. Of course this has always been my interest in global music—finding lost sounds and tones that are utterly foreign, yet strangely familiar.

Listening to all of these groups has reminded me how appropriate guitar-driven rhythms are during the summer. Overdriven, clean, slashing, it doesn't matter. Crunching guitars just sound so much better in stale heat and hot winds. As a testimony to the flexibility of the instrument, you can easily identify countless musicians or bands from just a couple opening chords. There is list after list of the most recognizable guitar tones in the music business. They all read something like this: Stevie Ray Vaughan, Jimi Hendrix, Carlos Santana, Tom Morello, blah blah blah, Slash, ugh. The beautiful thing about the guitar is that there is no end to this list. Whether artists are revolutionizing the instrument or just capitalizing on a single produced sound, the opportunities to create distinct tones seem endless. So for kicks, here're a couple of artists that we should keep in mind next time we talk about unmistakable guitar kingship.       
 
Dinosaur Jr.: This is by far the easiest band to add to the list. J Mascis is considered by many to have one of the most distinctive guitar sounds in rock—from the way "Little Fury Things" bursts open with its extended crunching solos to the more subdued melancholy of a song like "Start Choppin'." What's even more impressive is how complimentary the guitar tones are to Mascis' voice. This is probably best illustrated on "Freak Scene," with Mascis singing in his indifferent drawl over layers of churning guitar and a blistering outro. Simply put, the guitars match the vocals unbelievably well and few bands have that luxury.

The Exploding Hearts: Guitar Romantic is so undeniably genuine that it even manages to win over the most disaffected hardcore scenesters. Everything about the band should be contrived: the wise ass, childish lyrical themes, and the completely indulgent pop guitar. But somehow their only proper record avoids all artifice, creating a sound that could fit right in in 1970s new wave power-punk. There are so many musical elements that make Guitar Romantic enjoyable, but the bouncy melodies are most noticeably propelled by the guitar work of Terry Six. Every song on Guitar Romantic features at least one ripping solo, with particular attention given to "Throwaway Style," "Rumors in Town," and "Modern Kicks." Incidentally, Terry Six was one of the only members to survive the band's tragic auto accident in 2003. Three years later, Dirtnap Records released Shattered, a second disc of rarities and unfinished tracks added to the original Guitar Romantic lineup. Even on that album, Six's jangly, poppy guitar stands out. There's no way of mistaking the lead in to the title track with Six strumming alongside some giddy cowbell. Few bands have ever been as irreverent, hedonistic, or catchy as the Hearts. And don't expect that changing any time soon.

The Feelies: I don't know why the Feelies never really broke into the mainstream. Maybe if they had released their debut album Crazy Rhythms 10 years later than they did, they could have ridden Pavement's coattails to indie nerd success. But hell, it doesn't really matter. How can you fault a band for going against the grain and creating a sound distinctly separate from the mesh of its counterparts? Even though the band is classically known for its overextended percussion section, what really catches my ear is the frenetic, multi-layered guitars. Bill Million and Glenn Mercer go from melodic to spastic in the blink of an eye. On "Loveless Love," guitar stabs build up until at about the 1:45 mark, they let loose in an interweaving duel. The band likes to alternate between percussion breakdowns and isolated guitar picks to create suspense. "Crazy Rhythm" undergoes a cowbell/bass drum solo for a solid 40 seconds before the guitars come back in to tie it together to the rest of the song. Like most of their songs, it's odd, charming, and enjoyably delirious.

Les Savy Fav: I don't have the same kind of affection for Les Savy Fav as I do for Dinosaur Jr. or the Exploding Hearts. But I'm nonetheless completely drawn in by the band's muscular, echoey guitar tones. When Seth Jabour isn't selling fragrances (http://stereogum.com/archives/quit-your-day-job/quit-your-day-job-les-savy-fav_006203.html) he's creating gorgeous melodies that have just enough edge to keep up with Tim Harrington's bombastic yelps. "We'll Make a Lover of You" and "Our Costal Hymn" are perfect examples of Jabour steering the direction of the band. He provides so much bulk in just a few repeated strokes. Jabour's contributions to the band are even more apparent on Les Savy Fav's newest release, the audience friendly Let's Stay Friends. Just listen to "Patty Lee" and tell me the guitar isn't the most memorable thing about the song. Well, with the exception of Harrington screaming, "Back before Babylon, shit was cool!"

This list will always be a work in progress. Which gives us the right to kick some people off who have held posts for too long, or whose music we don't really give a shit about. In the end don't worry. You won't hurt Slash's feelings. There are things he cares about more than making your top 10 guitar sounds list. You know, like winning a Grammy or something.

Discussion
  • If we're talking purely about guitar sounds and not solos, it's criminal to not include Johnny Marr here.

    Responses to this comment
  • Ditto on Johnny Marr. And what about Jeff Beck, Clapton, Duane Allman, and, for a recognizable sound, George Harrison?

    Responses to this comment
  • Man, snorelock is Reggae Dude and I imagine Sourpuss is a Colt-45-and-handlebar-mustache classic-rock guy. Am I in the wrong club?

    Responses to this comment
  • Don't know about Rasta Snorelock, but I'm betting that Mr. Filthy, despite his name, is a charter member of the Billy Joel fan club.

    Responses to this comment
  • I feel like the problem with talking about Clapton, Allman, etc is that we've already talked about them for years and years and years. And they certainly deservethe attention but frankly they aren't my generation. And it seems like we gloss over artists from the 90s and today and jump straight to these guys because 60s and 70s are synonymous with awesome rock and awesome guitar. But hey don't overlook these sick musicians who are still in their prime.

    Responses to this comment
  • RIP J Dilla, Sourpuss.

    Responses to this comment
  • And I imagine, Mr. Filthy, you only like bands that play in local, small clubs, since, of course, everything main stream is garbage.

    Responses to this comment
  • I'll take Gabriel Baker's point, but not Filthy Funky Joel's. But Gabriel, you sort of did stir up things by invoking the horrendous Slash.

    Responses to this comment
  • Ha. Clearly I just expect him to Google his name, find this article, and then eventually give me his autograph. I love Slash.

    Responses to this comment
  • I think you could make an alright case for Sonic youth, and a name you never hear from classic rock is dickey betts, one of the guys from allman brothers who wrote alot of their best songs, and could put down a great solo (see Blue Sky and Jessica). I think hes much better than clapton and up there with duane. But you have to look past the fact that the average nashville studio musician in country/bluegrass could absolutely ruin 99.9% of the dudes on a "best guitarists" list, and that the average jazz guitar player could take them out. Not just straight ahead jazz but jazz funk/fusion (see Bill Connors, Larry Coryell, or john scofield). But why should a list like best guitarist include other genres besides rock.

    Responses to this comment
  • European Oils

    Responses to this comment
  • Marr, Clapton, Allman, Beck, what happened to all of these guys? You excluded all of the best guitarists in the world.

    Responses to this comment
  • Sonic Youth's guitar wizardry is on an entirely different plane of reality. Ditto for Jim O'Rourke and his various solo projects.

    Responses to this comment
  • Jesus Eatsmacoroni (I will assume your real name is Philbert Brambley) the point of all this is not looking at the same 5 guitar players. Unless you are some level of crazy that thinks clapton is underrated. And honestly who actually listens to jeff beck. He is a name that is thrown around too much. There are tons of guys that do what he does better than him, its just a semi-hip name to know. I mean honestly what's you're favorite jeff beck album.

    Responses to this comment
  • I think people and publications (especially Rolling Stone) confuse themselves when they discuss the "greatest guitarists of all time." Placing the emphasis on talent, innovation, or simply what sounds good will produce different lists. For example, some of the eighties hair metal guitarists are arguable more talented than several of the classic rock legends, but they lacked innovation and are generally not recognized in the "canon".

    Responses to this comment
  • Hey Billy, my favorite Beck album is Blow by Blow. Have you ever heard of it?

    Responses to this comment
  • Demain, maybe a few examples of said "hair metal guitarists," please.

    Responses to this comment
  • First off, let me say my top three fave guitarists are Hendrix and Page/Clapton (still can't decide who takes the cake on that one). As far as hair metal goes, from a technical standpoint, the solos those guys ripped out were incredible and extremely difficult to play. C.C. Deville, Eddie Van Halen, and Kirk Hammett (not really hair metal) are pretty good examples. What makes Hendrix the greatest is that he was doing the same thing while everyone in America was still bopping around to the Beatles and the Stones.

    Responses to this comment
  • Like I mentioned earlier, for all those Hendrix fans out there, you should really check out Group Doueh. Here is a link to stream some tracks: http://hypem.com/artist/group+doueh

    Responses to this comment
  • My dad went to Hendrix shows in the late 60s, before the guitarist croaked, and still swears by him. Growing up with all that stuff, I think Hedrix, with the exception of "Bold as Love" is dated, and nothing he did could touch "Beck's Bolero."

    Responses to this comment
  • 80s hair band solos = technically difficult technically difficult without composition, feel, and innovation = farting a symphony in an empty room ex: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xir6EVkzDws

    Responses to this comment
  • dude what? Hendrix sounds dated to you, but jeff beck doesn't? Am i losing my mind. I would take the guitar mastery of little wing, wind cries mary and castles made of sand any day over any of this: http://www.amazon.com/Blow-Jeff-Beck/dp/B00005AREQ haha listen to the preview on the second track, he's got the talking effect on his guitar And i see the point about 80s metal solos being difficult, but thats not what being musical is about man. Those guys are essentially playing the same solo every song. Any idiot can work on just being fast, and if thats all you want to hear than listen to that japanese trumpet playing robot.

    Responses to this comment
  • That's all I've been saying the whole time. The solos are technically difficult but the artists lack innovation. I thought I was clear on that, but I guess not. 80's hair metal is obviously not "all I want to hear." As far as Jimi goes, I think it's pretty ludicrous to say that he's dated. He's constantly imitated and listed as an influence of just about every major guitarist out there today, and his songs are constantly covered (for the record, John Mayer's Bold as Love makes me want to vomit).

    Responses to this comment
  • BillyIdol, I think you forfeited the high ground by claiming Dickey Betts (competent) was on the same level as Clapton, etc. As for Hendrix, obviously he was hugely influential, as was Sly Stone, but the bulk of his catalog hasn't aged well.

    Responses to this comment
  • I'd have to agree with the j mascis pick, he's a phenomenal guitarist. his appearance resembles his guitar tone: muddy, dirty, drenched in the swamp, covered in wah-wah weeds.

    Responses to this comment
  • John Mayer makes me vomit, except when he does hip-hop.

    Responses to this comment
  • I hate Mayer, too. Especially Waiting on the World to Change, that song just sucks.

    Responses to this comment
  • Dickey betts solo stuff does suck, but some of his solos on allman brothers stuff is pretty great (blue sky in particular. its pretty hard to play like that, and not that many guys can do it). I'm kind of biased against Clapton. I like derek and the dominos and cream and all that early stuff, but I think that the unplugged blues cd (you know the one with slow layla and a bunch of standards on it) is the worst damn clean-white-people-dumbing -down of the blues I've ever heard. I hate that album with a passion. So whatever. Anyways, whats that mayer song that gets played on the radio thats got the lyrics "I wanna run through the halls of my high school..." I think its him but I'm not sure. When i heard that line I laughed and almost had a car accident. Did anyone see him on Conan, when conan went to chicago, and he played some blues and mouthed off like he was some kind of expert and not some pop guy.

    Responses to this comment
  • BillyIdol, we're finally in agreement. Clapton, post-Derek and the Dominoes, mostly sucked. I can't listen to more than 10 seconds of a John Mayer song, and his frequent appearances on Gawker (for stupid gossip) make me skip that site more often than not.

    Responses to this comment
  • Are you kidding me? No Ratatat? MASSIVE guitar tones.

    Responses to this comment
  • Pardon me for being a traditionalist, but Mike Bloomfield and Duane Allman top the charts for me.

    Responses to this comment
  • Ira Kaplan of Yo La Tengo does some of the best (and most distinctive) noise guitar solos I've ever heard. Damn good when I saw them at Pitchfork Music Fest back in '05.

    Responses to this comment
  • Just saw Johnny Marr play with Modest Mouse last night and I have to agree with filthy&funky. While he was incredible with Morrisey and the Smiths, the combo of Marr and Brock is mind-blowing.

    Responses to this comment
  • bernard butler?

    Responses to this comment

Register or Login to leave a comment