The suit filed by the Recording
Industry Association of America has yet to go to trial, but Nesson's
recent tactics have drawn criticism, even among the association's most
outspoken foes. In the past few weeks, he has tape-recorded a telephone
conference with a federal judge and opposing counsel, and then - after
US District Judge Nancy Gertner of Boston told him to shut it off -
posted the record ing on his blog and featured it in a take-home exam
on evidence for his students.
Nesson
also posted dissenting e-mails from academics he had hoped to call as
expert witnesses for the defense but who rejected his legal theory that
Joel Tenenbaum had the right to download songs under the fair use
doctrine of copyright law. And he put up a four-minute recording of his
wife, Fern, a former Harvard law student of Nesson's, denigrating the
experts as misguided naysayers and one of Nesson's law students working
on the case as a "schmuck."
Lawyerly theater
The ongoing court battle over copyright protection and illegal downloading is getting a little more over the top.